Girl Scout Lovin’

Happy Monday! How happy are you that we are ONE day away from March? Which means we are just weeks away from Spring!!! I hope this makes you as happy as it makes me 🙂

This weekend was extremely busy and filled with food. 6 hours of my Saturday was spent cooking for my Grandma’s birthday. Thankfully I have an amazing boyfriend who helped me out A LOT in the kitchen…until the beer got there 😉 Our menu included : Sesame Ginger Shrimp, Baked Potato Nachos, Pasta A la Vodka Chicken Casserole, French Bread, Spinach – Goat Cheese – Apple – Raisins  & Candied Walnut Salad, Tagalong Cake and S’mores Cookies! I bet you can guess what I wore all day yesterday… Extreme stretchy pants from food overload! Everything turned out perfect which is a plus for you because that means I have recipes to share 🙂

Sunday, I promised the recipe that included TWO boxes of Girl Scout Tagalongs. Chocolate + Peanut Butter = the dangerously delicious most perfect combination ever.

Tagalong Cake


  • 1 box of Devils Food Cake  + ingredients you will need to make this (or make your own)
  • 2 boxes of Girl Scout Tagalong cookies
  • 1/2 cup Peanut Butter
  • 16 oz tub of Cool Whip
  • 1/4 cup Powdered Sugar


  • Pre-heat oven to 350 degrees
  • Prepare cake mix as prepared on box
  • Chop 1 box of Tagalongs into small pieces

  • Add them to the batter

  • Pour batter into two greased 8 inch rounds

  • Cook for 3-4 minutes less than recommended on box
  • Remove from oven when toothpick comes out clean
  • Cool completely then remove from rounds to a platter

  • Chop 1/2 of the tagalongs into small pieces from the 2nd box
  • Warm the peanut butter slightly and fold it into half of the tub of cool whip

  • Slowly add 1/4 cup of the powdered sugar and mix well
  • Spread the peanut butter filling between the layers

  • Mix the rest of the cool whip with the remainder of the chopped tagalong cookies and frost the outside of cake.
  • Cut the last of the tagalongs in half and add them to the top of the cake

  • Refrigerate until ready to serve – Serve chilled

Look at the cookie pieces in the cake! I’m not a HUGE fan of chocolate cake but this cake takes the cake. Know what I’m sayin?

This deserves a total foodgasm face.

Next time you see those cute little girls at the grocery store asking you for $5 to buy a sinful treat say yes…and make this cake!

I have a couple more recipes from Saturday to share with you but I’m wrapped up in the Bachelor right now so I will save them for later on this week. Sneak peak…

In case you didn’t know – Tomorrow is National Pancake Day! If you don’t have time to stop by iHOP for your free pancakes then feel free to make one of my recipes… I bet mine taste better anyways 😉

Protein Pumpkin Pancakes

Cottage Cheese Pancakes

Funfetti Pancakes

Whole Wheat Cinnamon Apple Swirl w/ Apple Topping Pancakes

Oatmeal Cinnamon Raisin Crepe Pancakes

Pumpkin Raisin Pancakes for One

Not to mention they will save you hundreds of calories. Indulge a little…

QUESTIONS: Will you be celebrating National Pancake Day? What is your favorite girl scout cookie? Have you ever made a dessert with Girl Scout cookies?

36 Responses to “Girl Scout Lovin’”

  1. Love thin mints!! I bet they would be delicious in a milk/protein shake!

  2. Currently watching the Bachelor too!! LOVEEEE!!

  3. Thin Mints FTW! I love them so much, but hate what they do to my waistline. 😦 Oh well, I still eat them, I just make sure I don’t buy more than one box! 🙂

  4. National pancake day? I’m definitely going to have to find a way to celebrate! 🙂

    I hope your grandma’s birthday was amazing! I’m sure all that yummy sounding food and your presence made it a day to remember (in an awesome way, of course)! 😀

    Wow! That cake looks truly out of this world!!!

  5. For anyone who may be wondering…The Tag-along Cake was AMAZING!

  6. I didn’t even know it was National Pancake Day!! I will not be celebrating just bc pancakes are such a calorie splurge. I love your pancake recipes tho 🙂

  7. That cake is some kind of wonderful-and that pasta-yummy!!!
    National pancake day? WHAT?! LOVE THAT!

  8. Love tag-alongs and thin mints – so delicious!
    Can you believe I haven’t bought a box of GS cookies this year though?! I’ve resisted the urge!!

  9. That Tagalong cake looks amazing!!! You seriously could be a professional chef. Your recipes are amazing!!!

  10. hellz to the yes I’m celebrating PANCAKE DAY!!! Totally one of the best days of the year; and I love that you posted all your recipes for them! mmm Pumpkin protein sound absolutely delish…. I made some over the weekend that were a total flop but still tasted REALLY good! Anyway, that cake looks SO yummy! Give me anything with PB AND CHOCOLATE!

  11. Food porn!! Seriously, that cake looks soo good!!

  12. Heck yes to National Pancake day. Your food seriously looks like the Om nom nom nom. ]

    I had pumpkin pancakes this morning which were amazing. I don’t live anywhere near an Ihop other wise I would go there.

  13. You did a kick-butt job on that cake!! Shh, don’t tell my boyfriend its pancake day or he’ll expect me to whip some up for him! lol

  14. I didnt know today was national pancake day!! I guess its not too late, breakfast for dinner?! oh and that cake looks AMAZING!!

  15. dear alyssa,

    i like yo style.

    love, alyssa.

    p.s. I’m thinking SAMOA BROWNIES. yes? YES.

  16. This Tagalong cake looks so delicious. I absolutely love it. Thanks for providing this recipe to it. I never heard of this but I will definitely make sure to make it.

  17. I WILL be celebrating NAtional pancake day! Hoping to have a new recipe up tomorrow! Also, that face is hilarious about eating the cake! I do this often with many foods I try! haha

  18. omg, that tagalong cake is just EVIL! Wish I’d never seen it! ; )

  19. L ove Tagalongs and Thin Mints. I’ve downed a box or two already this girl scout cookie season!
    The pasta dish looks yummy too!
    Today is Peanut Butter Lover’s Day!

  20. I wish I could still eat Girl Scout cookies! No GF ones 😦 womp, womp. I love both peanut butter ones.
    That filling of PB & Cool Whip sounds so delicious! It’s so different and light 🙂 Love it!

  21. HAHA that is EXACTLY what my foodgasm face looks like!! SO darn attractive!! 😉 That cake looks AMAZING you absolute GENIUS! 😀

  22. I love pancakes. But ironically, I didn’t celebrate! Seems like I’m always a few days behind on such things (I do pancakes on the weekends…).

  23. I was JUST thinking about girl scount cookies today! They’ve already come and gone where we are, but I do like to homemake them. My favorite being Samoas. Ohhh my goodness those things are amazing. Love that cake, too!

  24. Aww, yeah, it’s easy to get wrapped up in The Bachelor, I hear ya!

    I love pancakes so much! I didn’t realize today was national pancake day, though! I think I might have to have a couple tonight just to celebrate! 🙂

  25. The cake was pure pleasure. It was AMAZING!!!!!!! Not to mention the dinner itself. Lyss, you outdid yourself and you maintained your high fashion style while doing it. Let me just say, Alyssa was preparing this huge meal for 14 in her high heel, thigh high boots. You are beautiful sweetie:) Love you

  26. TAGALONG CAKE?! that is the most brilliant thing i have ever heard.

  27. Holy mama! That cake!!! I’d die and go to SUGAR COMA Heaven but oh my my it looks wonderful! Someday I’ll try it… lol

    And that last cheese covered whatever looks incredible!

  28. That cake looks too good to be true!

  29. Um, I’m not a big cake person either but I would eat this WHOLE thing by myself. Delicious! I need to find some Girl Scouts soon.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: